Menu
Archives

'Let the book of the past be closed'

MOUNTAIN MEADOWS, Utah -- "Let the book of the past be closed. Let peace come into our hearts. Let friendship and love be extended. May the peace of heaven be felt over this hallowed ground is my prayer," said President Gordon B. Hinckley as he spoke to about 1,000 people gathered in a remote corner of Utah.

The gathering, held Sept. 11, was about 30 miles northwest of St. George among sage and scrub cedar-carpeted hills at the site where the Baker-Fancher Wagon Train met its tragic end in 1857. To memorialize those pioneers, the Church rebuilt a cairn, rocks piled as a monument, originally erected in 1859, and on this, the 142nd anniversary of the atrocity, President Hinckley dedicated the monument. The meeting was conducted by Elder Dennis B. Neuenschwander of the Seventy and president of the Utah South Area.In attendance were descendants of those in the wagon train along with descendants of the Iron County Militia and others from nearby Mormon settlements at whose hands the tragedy -- the forfeiture of the lives of 120 people in the wagon train -- occurred. One man who was involved, John D. Lee, was executed for his part.

Emotions were near the surface as descendants of both groups wept and called upon the Lord to "continue the healing" of the deep wounds experienced by many for the past 142 years. To help in the healing process, Ronald E. Loving, a relative of Capt. Alexander Fancher, and Verne Lee, president of the John D. Lee family association, jointly began the Mountain Meadows Association in 1989.

Speaking at the dedication, Mr. Loving, said:

"These people who died so horribly so far from family and friends will now forever be cared for by as much reverence and love as any family can give. The families of the Baker-Fancher train are forever linked to the LDS Church and the Mormon people. Let us now look at this event as a historical incident that took place in the American West, and turn our relationships into one of friendship and tolerance for one another's religion and culture. I declare this land in their memory, in addition to being hallowed, sacred ground, to be neutral ground where only love, tolerance, and understanding can be brought."

The service was sent by satellite to meetinghouses in Arkansas, southern Utah, the Salt Lake area and Idaho where it was viewed by additional descendants of both groups in an effort to provide emotional closure to a painful chapter of history. Music was provided by a large, combined choir from St. George West and Enterprise stakes.

The cairn monument and grounds were recently completed by contractors whose efforts were supplemented by nearly 4,000 hours of donated labor by up to 1,000 local members and friends.

President Hinckley dedicated the area with the promise that the Church "will be here as long as the earth lasts, and it will take care of this place."

"This is a solemn and significant occasion," President Hinckley told those in attendance. "This is an emotional experience for me. I come as peacemaker. This is not a time of recrimination or the assigning of blame. No one can explain what happened in these meadows 142 years ago. We may speculate, but we do not know. We do not understand it. We cannot comprehend it. We can only say the past is long since gone. It cannot be recalled. It cannot be changed. It is time to leave the entire matter in the hands of God who deals justly in all things. His is a wisdom far beyond our own."

When he arrived at the site, President Hinckley walked around the flower-adorned monument and silently paid his respects. The monument of piled stones -- each one hand-cleaned by volunteers -- is surrounded by a low, inner stone fence and taller iron outer fence. Such a cairn was originally placed on the grave-site by Col. James H. Carleton in 1859 after his soldiers buried the victims. It was rebuilt several times over the years. One of those rebuildings was in 1932 when the Church re-erected the cairn.

President Hinckley told how he and his father visited Mountain Meadows 50 years ago and viewed the monument.

"My father said nothing. I said nothing. We simply stood there and thought of what occurred here. The cairn was here. Weeds rustled in the breeze. We walked back to the car without speaking. We knew this ground was hallowed, and we were reverent and respectful."

He recalled when he dedicated a marker on a nearby hillside in 1990 and descendants of both groups were also in attendance. A descendant of John D. Lee, Rex Lee, then president of BYU, "asked all to stand and join hands in a gesture of friendship. We felt a spirit of peace on that occasion and a spirit of appreciation for one another."

President Hinckley described the development of the monument. "The walls of the cairn have been rebuilt and stabilized. The dressed stone has been placed along the top of the walks. We have not spared expense to do it right and to do it in a fashion that will remain through the years.

"Many, many people have participated. Volunteers have worked very hard. We are grateful to everyone. . . . I am grateful that I have had the opportunity to further this effort. All of my associates of the First Presidency and Council of the Twelve Apostles of the Church are united in what we have done.

"I sit in the chair that Brigham Young occupied as President of the Church at the time of the tragedy. I have read very much of the history of what occurred here. There is no question in my mind that he was opposed to what happened. Had there been a faster means of communication, it never would have happened and history would have been different. That which we have done here must never be construed as an acknowledgement on the part of the Church of any complicity in the occurrences of that fateful and tragic day.

"But we have an obligation. We have a moral responsibility. We have a Christian duty to honor, respect, and to do all feasible to remember and recognize those who died here. May this cairn stand as a sacred monument to honor all of those who fell, wherever they might have been buried in these Mountain Meadows."

In his dedicatory prayer, President Hinckley petitioned: "Forgive our sins, dear Father. Take from our hearts bitterness and rancor. Instill within us a spirit of love, an outreach toward one another.

"The fires of bitterness and suspicion have burned long enough, O Lord. Let the sunlight of goodwill shine upon us. Dry the tears of those who have wept over these events. Open their eyes to an understanding of Thine all-encom-passing love. Touch their hearts with a feeling of appreciation for one for another as we mingle together on this day of reconciliation. There has been enough of weeping and grieving. This is the time to take upon ourselves the mantle of Thy Beloved Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, who gave His life as a ransom for the sins of all men. We, thy servants, have done all we know how to do to enshrine in this sanctuary the memories of the victims."

Elder Neuenschwander, in his remarks, observed, "deep feelings have surrounded the telling and re-telling of the event. But that which was broken can be repaired, and that which was wounded can be healed. The reconstruction of and dedication of this memorial is an important step toward a much-welcomed reconciliation."

He described the dedication of the monument as "both an ending and a beginning. After 142 years it is time to bring some feelings to an end. A new era is opening for all of us today as we participate in the dedication of this memorial on land made sacred by those who suffered and died here."

A day earlier, on Sept. 10, descendants and relatives of members of the Baker-Fancher wagon train held a two-hour memorial service at the re-interment of the remains of 29 men, women, children and one infant. These remains were accidently uncovered when the monument was being constructed. The remains were placed in four small coffins, built lovingly of pine and lined with handwoven cloth. Handmade flags of 1851 draped each coffin and were given to the descendants who have grieved for four generations. The relatives poured samples of earth from historic sites in Arkansas into the burial vault so that the deceased "would rest on Arkansas soil." Relatives carried the small coffins to a corner of the monument where they were placed in a concrete vault.

The handmade flags, the cloth, and the coffins were made and donated by Church members and friends.

At this meeting, Elder Neuenschwander explained that local Church members have "hand-cleaned the rocks, polished the fence, and done everything and anything that was asked of them. Their expression was also for those descendants of militia -- this memorial and all the hours that have gone into it are an expression of love."

The services included a sermon from the Rev. Stanton Cram of Springdale, Ark., who has served as a minister to descendants and is married to the former Virginia Fancher, a descendant. Judge Roger V. Logan Jr., of Harrison, Ark., a longtime student of the massacre and relative of 27 Dunlap and Mitchell emigrants, described the "unfortunate affair."

"It can be explained, but it cannot ever be justified. But, thankfully, that is not the end of the story. We are finding out that we are good people on both sides, decent people -- people who want to do the right thing. . . . . All of this provides us with hope, hope that this old story filled with bitterness, will no longer have to cause people, people of a different heritage, to distrust and dislike one another."

In later comments, he said, "No one in this world today has any blame for that, and we don't have any right to hold this evil against the Mormon Church, or the people here. They have just been wonderful, they have done wonderful work, they have been gracious hosts and helped us in any way they could."

That evening, on Sept. 10, at a dinner in the nearby town of Washington, attended by 400 descendants of both groups, additional insights were shared by Shane Baker, a BYU archaeologist, and Clint Lytle, whose family has owned the Mountain Meadows property for two generations and deeded the monument site to the Church. Both men wept as they spoke of the emotion of encountering the remains, and the attachment they felt toward the deceased pioneers of the Baker-Fancher wagon train.

"Ron [Loving] and I held each other when we looked at those bones," said Brother Lytle. "Those were people we cared for. I thought, 'Now they can rest properly.' There is a place for them where they are safe. It is hard for me, to know in that land I love, such a thing happened. My hope is that the land will no longer be a place of tragedy, but a place where your ancestors may rest in peace."

Following the dedication ceremony Sept. 11, a grandson of survivor Triphenia Fancher, Paul Wilson, a self-described Oklahoma cowboy, said, "I thank President Hinckley and the LDS Church for the money they spent. I think it was a great gesture, but I think more so than that was effort of the Mormon people who contributed to the building and reconstruction -- that is something that money doesn't always buy."

Newsletters
Subscribe for free and get daily or weekly updates straight to your inbox
The three things you need to know everyday
Highlights from the last week to keep you informed