Editor’s note: This is part one in a series on the essential role of councils in the Church, beginning with the Council of the First Presidency and Quorum of the Twelve Apostles and extending to stake, ward and family councils. Read more in part two, part three and part four.
When asked what he has learned about the importance of councils in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, President Dallin H. Oaks, first counselor in the First Presidency, thinks back to an experience he had in his late 20s.
President Oaks was a newly called second counselor of a stake presidency in Chicago, Illinois, at the time. In one of the first meetings he attended, the stake president indicated a stake center needed to be built to accommodate the large number of units in the stake.
The stake president suggested the stake center could be located in the western suburb of Naperville and asked what his counselors thought. “The first counselor said he thought that was a good idea,” President Oaks recalled. “And I said, ‘I think that’s a bad idea.’”
After a few minutes of discussion in which President Oaks outlined his concerns with the location, the stake president invited his counselors to pray about the decision and plan to talk about it at their next meeting.
“The instant I put it before the Lord,” President Oaks said, “I got as strong an impression as I’ve ever had: You’re wrong. Get out of the way.”
At the next meeting, he was on board with building the stake center in Naperville.
“The purpose of the council was to introduce a subject and to stimulate me to prayer, and with the benefit of revelation, I came in line,” President Oaks said. “We had what the Lord wanted — unity — and a stake center was built. And yes, you’ll find it in the western suburbs of Chicago. It’s not where I thought it ought to be, but it’s where the Lord wanted it.”
Seated shoulder to shoulder in President Henry B. Eyring’s office in the Church Administration Building, President Oaks and President Eyring, second counselor in the First Presidency, recently spoke to the Church News about the essential role of councils in the Church and the revelatory process that comes through counseling in the Lord’s way.
Inviting a revelatory process
As he reflected on his experience in Chicago, President Oaks said he remains grateful the stake president invited input instead of forcing a decision.
Had the stake president said something like: “The Lord told me it should be in Naperville. Will you sustain me?” President Oaks said: “I would have sustained him. But the process wasn’t complete.”
President Eyring remembers observing a similar principle the first time he attended a meeting with the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles. Not yet an Apostle at the time, President Eyring was a guest at the meeting.
As he watched the Brethren discuss an item, “I thought they had reached, after a lot of differences of opinion, a consensus,” he recalled. “And the President of the Church who was in the chair said: ‘I sense there is someone in the room who is not settled yet. We’ll bring it back another time.’”
President Eyring said as they filed out of the room, he noticed a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles tell the President of the Church, “Thank you.”
Whether in a meeting with the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, a stake presidency meeting or even a family council, “the great leader of a council is very sensitive to that — not to try to force unanimity or consensus but wait until it actually happens,” President Eyring said.
Counseling in the First Presidency
Even with decades of Church service, President Oaks and President Eyring — who President Russell M. Nelson called to serve as his counselors when he was sustained as President of the Church in January 2018 — continue to learn principles of decision-making from President Nelson’s leadership.
“I sat beside President Nelson for about 34 years before he was called as President of the Church, and I was called into the First Presidency,” President Oaks said. “In the Quorum of the Twelve, President Nelson was a member of the Council of the Twelve Apostles. He was not the decision-maker.
“What I have learned serving with President Nelson is that he is a different man when the mantle of the Lord settles upon him, and he becomes the Lord’s Prophet, the President of the restored Church, and the ultimate decision-maker in the Church. I see him making decisions and giving counsel in a far different way than I saw in 34 years of sitting beside him in the Quorum of the Twelve.”
President Eyring has served in three different First Presidencies. Prior to serving with President Nelson, he was second counselor to President Gordon B. Hinckley and first counselor to President Thomas S. Monson.
“Each did it a very different way,” President Eyring said of how the presidents of the Church organized the First Presidency. “But what they had in common was a feeling of tremendous regard for their counselors and seeking their views.”
President Eyring said if they were meeting together and he wasn’t forthcoming with an opinion, they each might say: “Hal, you’ve got something on your mind. What is it? Speak up.”
In every case, the members of the First Presidency have brought unique insights and perspectives to items discussed.
“Every time an issue comes before the First Presidency, it’s fun to see he and I come at it slightly differently,” President Eyring said of President Oaks. “I know he has been a judge, and a great lawyer, and he’ll see some things that I can’t see. …
“He will often say after meeting, ‘Well, we came at it differently, and we came out together at the end.’ … It may not be the view that he or I had to begin with. It may be a joint thing that we’ve seen together.”
Of counseling with President Eyring, President Oaks said: “He sees problems and relevant facts that I didn’t even know existed. And then I apply my judgment and background, and when we get through, we listen to the Lord’s will through the one who presides in the council.”
The strength of councils
President Oaks said that as a person participating in a council has the opportunity to speak what is on his or her mind — “and if the other people are listening, with the thought that he might have something from the Lord that I don’t have yet,” President Eyring added — “then the process ends in unity, and unity comes from the Lord.
“And it’s the way the Lord blesses us,” President Oaks continued, “whether it’s a marriage, a Young Women presidency or elders [quorum] presidency. These are all examples of councils that we deal with. We seek revelation, and we come to unity, and we qualify for the blessings.”
Referencing President Nelson’s emphasis for Latter-day Saints to “keep on the covenant path,” President Oaks said, “We know that children of God are in different places on the covenant path … and that’s part of the function of councils, to help people at different points on the covenant path.”
From the Council of the First Presidency to a family council and all councils in between, “the strength of councils comes largely from the faith of the people who are in them,” President Eyring said.
“If they, together, feel that the Lord has something He wants done, and don’t know yet what it is … there is a chance that, together with their faith, they can find out the Lord’s will.”